• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Carmine's Italian Bakery: A Sweet Slice of Italy in Middletown

Carmine's Italian Bakery, nestled in the heart of Middletown, NY, has been a beloved destination for over 30 years. This family-run establishment is renowned for its delightful pastries, including the irresistible Raspberry Rugula and large, creamy Cannolis. With a commitment to quality, Carmine's offers freshly baked goods and a cozy atmosphere that encourages communal enjoyment. Customers rave about its scrumptious breakfast options and the warm, inviting service that feels like home. While the décor may be simple, the taste is exceptional, making Carmine's the perfect spot for anyone craving authentic Italian treats with a side of charm.

Carmine's Italian Bakery at a glance

  • Address 425 E Main St, Middletown, NY 10940, United States
  • Phone +1 845-344-0780
  • Restaurant type Bakery .

Photos & Gallery

Carmine's Italian Bakery: Reviews & Ratings

Martin Leggett
5

Places like this need to be protected at all cost. Amazing food, fantastic service. Family owned. The way it was before.

Christine ONeill
5

I have been going here for many years. They are the most wonderful people! All of the baked goods are huge, fresh and full of flavor. They have the best Italian cookies, apple turnovers, black and white cookies, pastries, cakes and breads and much more. Their special holiday items are awesome too. They make very tasty sandwiches for breakfast and lunch, which are generously stuffed and delish!!! Check them out!

Pooja Patel
5

I had such a wonderful experience here! The owners were incredibly sweet and welcoming, making me feel right at home. Their hospitality truly stood out. The food was absolutely fresh and delicious, everything tasted homemade with so much care put into it. From start to finish, it was such a pleasant visit. I’ll definitely be coming back and recommending this place to everyone! :))))

Lianna Hoyt
5

A small but beautiful bakery, I've been semi regular there for the past few months and the workers are some of the best I've seen. Their prices are fair and their sandwiches delicious. Their bread is always fluffy and their customer service amazing, asking about recent sports matches and overall being delightful people.

Maria
5

The family and staff are wonderful! The pastries, especially the unique Italian pastries are delicious!

jason dessereau
5

awesome classic place. amazing pastries. black and white cookie was to die for everything in there was larger than life. staff was super friendly and accommodating. will definitely be back

Nick Connelly
5

Placed an order for Biscottis and Cannolis! They were a huge hit at our party! Can’t wait to get more. Very friendly, local and family owned business. Prices are very fair and quality is unmatched.

Easha Ahmed
5

The owners were so kind! such a inviting place and food was bomb, the donuts were super fluffy! and the bagel was very soft :)

Location

  • Carmine's Italian Bakery
    Carmine's Italian Bakery
    425 E Main St, Middletown, NY 10940, United States Hotline: +1 845-344-0780

Welcome to Carmine's Italian Bakery, a beloved gem nestled in the heart of Middletown, New York. This charming bakery, located at 415 E Main St, stands as a testament to Italian baking traditions and a warm family atmosphere. With its unpretentious exterior and inviting aromas, Carmine's offers a slice of Italy right in the community.

Carmine's Italian Bakery specializes in a variety of delights that keep customers coming back for more. Their menu is bursting with tempting options, from classic raspberry rugula to decadent large cannolis. Each item is crafted with care, embodying both flavor and tradition. Notably, their assortment of cookies, including the ever-popular black and white cookies, is a highlight that brings joy to many locals and visitors alike.

  • Bakery Items:
    • Raspberry Rugula - $14.95/lb
    • Black and White Cookies - $2.75 each
    • Apple Turnovers - $2.75 each
    • Large Cannolis - $3.75 each
  • Breakfast Sandwiches:
    • Bacon Egg and Cheese on a Roll - $3.75
    • Sausage Egg and Cheese on a Roll - $3.75

Customers rave about the exceptional quality of the pastries, often referring to them as "out of this world." With everyday offerings like hot bread and freshly cooked breakfast sandwiches, Carmine's presents an outstanding value in comparison to other establishments in town. As one patron aptly noted, "the coffee is brewed fresh every 20 minutes or less," ensuring a perfect pairing with any sweet treat.

While some visitors feel the décor could use an update, they recognize that the real star here is the mouthwatering selection of pastries. The bakery perfectly captures the essence of a family-run establishment; the light-hearted banter between staff often makes for a delightful visit. It’s places like this that offer not just food, but a sense of community and connection.

As you step into Carmine's, prepare to be welcomed by the delectable aromas that fill the air. Whether it's your first visit or you're a long-time fan like Grace H., who has been treating herself for over 30 years, each bite is a celebration of authentic Italian baking. So don't forget to stop by for an indulgent experience – why not make it a sweet stop today?

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
  • Service options
    • Offers takeaway
    • Delivery
    • Same-day delivery